The fact that The Artist is a black and white silent film makes all the difference. It was a unique kind of film experience. Our eyes soaked up the perfect shades of grey and understood the first language we ever learned; body language. Our ears were more relaxed, not searching words to decipher for meaning, but instead had music that perfectly lead us to the correct emotional state of each scene. Without booming voices and today’s typical loud things that happen in movies (explosions, gunfire, screaming, Michael Bay-style annoyances), the entire theater experience was quieter than expected and I could hear laughter from rows away. It was easy to see ourselves in the shots of audiences watching movies.
George Valentin (Jean Dujardin) is a silent film star in 1927 who loves the attention it brings him. He is a bit conceited, giving his dog more credit than his costar and wife. When a fan bumps into him with photographers all around, George plays along, sparking the question, “Who’s that girl?” With her picture in the paper next to a star, she has more confidence and becomes an extra at Kinograph studios, under the name Peppy Miller (Supporting Actress nominated, Bérénice Bejo). Little did she know she would be working with George and that he would help her find the one thing that can make her stand out from the other girls. There is an obvious attraction between the two.
Problems arise for George, when he refuses to move on to talkies. At first, he laughs, thinking a talking film is ridiculous. When he understands the threat it presents to his work, he tries to fight it, by making his own silent film and making arguments against talkies in the papers. Soon, he realizes it is too late. We understand him to be a man stuck in one place as the rest of the world, including rising star Peppy, moves on without him. That staircase scene helped illustrate that idea perfectly, no words needed.
With his Clark Gable style looks and Fred Astaire moves, Best Actor nominated Jean Dujardin feels perfectly natural in this silent era role as George. All his “mugging at the camera” does not feel like mugging, but a perfect portrayal of emotions that can range so far across his face and movement. When he smiles, it’s joyous. His lowest moments can break our hearts. Even when George’s guard is up, Dujardin has a way of showing how George truly feels. This sort of silent acting is not miming, but a true art that has to reach deeper than superficial words, and Dujardin proves that he is a master.
I believe that music is much more important in a silent film. It sets the tone and can replace the voices some may miss. In one scene, you will see how orchestras used to play live at the front of the theater, providing live music to accompany the film. Ah, how I would love to experience a silent film the old fashioned way. The music composed for this film spans a wide range of depth, from toe-tapping jazzy to sweepingly dramatic. And it all keeps true to the era portrayed. If these points are taken into consideration, there is no competition against The Artist for Best Original Score.
Besides Best Picture, Original Score and the two acting nominations, The Artist was also nominated for Cinematography, Original Screenplay, Art Direction, Film Editing, Costume Design and Michel Hazanavicius for Best Director. That is a big 10 nominations for a film that seems so out of the ordinary. Only one other film has more nominations this year, Hugo with 11.
What surprised me the most about The Artist, is that even though there are some themes that hearken back to Singin’ in the Rain and Sunset Boulevard, it feels very original. I was not able -nor distracted enough to try- to guess what would happen next. The plot was driven by the characters, and they felt so real and compelling that the whole audience celebrated their triumphs and mourned beside them; even the dog.
The Artist gives me hope for the next generation of film making. Taking a step back and remembering exactly why we love film, what originally made it so great, is one of the best ways to improve upon this art. This is an amazing homage to an important era in film history that keeps the visuals and ideas simple. But most importantly, it puts story and character first.
If The Academy is looking to award the most unconditional film that celebrates why people have always loved the movies, The Artist will win the Oscar for Best Picture.
At the risk of sounding like a complete Phillistine, at one point I wondered whether the film should have been named “The Con-Artist”. It was a clever concept, but after about 15 minutes the novelty wore off for me. Now, I appreciate some of the old silent flicks, and their historical importance; but do I want to go to the cinema and sit through a silent film complete with mugging and over-dramitization for the camera?–not really. And I really don’t get all the hype over this film…At least they found an actor with as many teeth and as big a smile as Gene Kelly. I didn’t think that was possible.
On the positive side, Berenice Bejo was truly impressive and gave an outstanding performance. Even without the sound, I came to care about and like her character…very impressive! Technically, the film was brilliant, particularly the Art Direction and the Costumes. And that dog! He was my favorite character…loved him…An Oscar for the Uggie the Dog!
I’m sure my comments will irritate many of my fellow film buffs. Sorry, folks. Obviously we can’t all agree on every film.
This was a very well-made film and had its moments where it captures the whole spirit and essence of the silent film era but it’s not that life-changing experience that everybody says it is. Still, a good flick though and I do think it does still deserve the Best Picture Oscar just because I don’t think The Descendants would be a very good winner that will last for the ages. Good review.
Sounds good. I suppose its a neat idea, but really, I have to make the argument that sound in film is a vast improvement. It is important to look back and remember the brilliance of the pioneers of film. But there’s a reason that no one has made a silent film between 1927 till now.
Ian,
that was kind of my point. to appreciate the past without necessarily feeling the need to recreate it. It really was kinda cute for a while; but soon wore off. I’ve got several silent films in my DVD collection but really have to be in a special frame of mind to sit and watch for an extended period. Here, the final scene was just too clever with the 30 seconds of sound. But the visuals were impressive…and that dog!
Was the dog a throwback to Asta from The Thin Man movies?
I have to admit that I don’t own any silent films. The only one I would consider buying is City Lights if it was released on Bluray.
Good thought…Uggie even looks kinda like Asta.
As far as Silent films, I have the standard “Wings”, “Birth of a Nation”, and “Intolerance”; but also Keaton’s “The General” and King Vidor’s “The Crowd” was great!
and the original “Ben-Hur” is a masterpiece in its own right.
Loved it! I don’t get the complaints about the gimmick (not calling anyone out in particular). To me that’s like saying Memento wouldn’t be the same without the editing and chronologically moving backwards. The gimmick is there to serve a purpose and I thought this movie did it wonderfully and the two leads (I know berenice is nominated for supporting, but she’s a lead) are perfect. Can’t wait to rewatch it…just such an enjoyable movie.
Wow, such a variety of responses, I love it! Thanks everyone!
I finally caught up with the Artist and share the reservations more than the enthusiasm. My guess is that it is a film that is terribly popular among movie professionals and among people who rarely go to the movies (what an odd combination…). The novelty of the format does wear off quickly for those who watch a lot of films professionally or privately, and then it comes down to the actors’ performance (pretty good here) and to story-telling. And in terms of story, The Artist does not have to offer too much, I am afraid… my notes: http://thomas4cinema.wordpress.com/2012/02/03/the-artist-michel-hazanavicius-2011/